Peter Billingsley settles debate: Die Hard Christmas movie vs A Christmas Story

"Die Hard" star Peter Billingsley makes a compelling case for why the action movie is a Christmas classic.

The debate over whether "Die Hard" is a Christmas movie has been reignited by "A Christmas Story" star Peter Billingsley, who made a compelling case to "Die Hard" cinematographer Jan de Bont on a recent episode of his podcast "A Cinematic Christmas Journey."

Billingsley argued that the film is bookended by two holiday-centric songs, including the Christmas classic "Let it Snow!" by Vaughn Monroe. He also pointed out the presence of Santas in the film's production design and the central location at a Christmas party. Additionally, he highlighted a scene where Bruce Willis's character, John McClane, uses a dead body to send a message, which he described as an "iconic 'ho ho ho' moment."

But Billingsley's most persuasive argument was that the film embodies the themes of Christmas, such as acceptance, forgiveness, love, and family.

De Bont, who was initially skeptical, ultimately accepted Billingsley's argument, leading to a joyful celebration between Billingsley and his co-host Steve Byrne.

"Die Hard," which premiered in July 1988, follows a New York City policeman attempting to save hostages taken captive by a terrorist group at a holiday party. Despite the debate, Bruce Willis has insisted that "Die Hard" is not a Christmas movie, declaring it to be a "Bruce Willis movie" during his 2018 Comedy Central Roast.

The debate continues, but Billingsley's persuasive arguments have certainly made a compelling case for considering "Die Hard" as a holiday classic.