J.J. McCarthy NFL draft projection and pro scouts' feedback

Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy's future is uncertain as he decides between the NFL Draft and returning to Michigan for his senior year.

Michigan Wolverines junior quarterback J.J. McCarthy faces a significant decision at the end of this season: return to Michigan for his senior year or enter the 2024 NFL Draft. McCarthy has an impressive 25-1 record as Michigan's QB1 and even ranked 10th in Heisman Trophy voting this season. His statistics are equally impressive, having thrown for 2,630 yards with 19 touchdowns and four interceptions, while also rushing for 146 yards and three scores. McCarthy currently ranks third in ESPN's Total QBR metric, second in the nation in completion percentage, and sixth in passer rating.

Given his dual-threat capabilities, steady accuracy, and strong arm, McCarthy is expected to be the highest-drafted quarterback in Michigan's history under coach Jim Harbaugh. Harbaugh himself has hailed McCarthy as a generational talent at the quarterback position, comparing him to Andrew Luck. While McCarthy has yet to announce his decision about the NFL, analysts have already included him in mock drafts and draft rankings.

Scouts and pundits have differing opinions about McCarthy's potential in the NFL. While some have expressed concerns about his performance in certain games and Michigan's emphasis on running the ball, others believe that McCarthy's skills will shine in the NFL. Despite his relatively low number of passing attempts, scouts have praised his efficiency and athleticism, predicting that he could rise in the draft rankings as the pre-draft process unfolds.

McCarthy's decision may be influenced by his performance in the upcoming games and the current landscape of the NFL draft. If he leads Michigan to a national championship, it could significantly impact his choice to enter the draft. However, returning to Michigan for another season could also allow him to further develop his skills and physical attributes, providing him with more opportunities to showcase his talents. Ultimately, McCarthy's decision will depend on various factors, including his performance, the draft class's competitiveness, and his long-term career goals.